It’s a debate capable of sparking heated debate. There are diehard charcoal grill fans and certainly many gas grill fanatics, each with strong points about which type of grill is better. Both sides made a strong case, with gas offering convenience and ease of use to offset the unmistakable smoky, charcoal flavor only a “kettle” grill can provide.
Learn the practical differences between charcoal and gas grills, plus a few tips to help you choose the best grilling set-up for you!
Both charcoal and gas grills are relatively easy ways to prepare meals outdoors - that’s obvious. The fuel source has a massive impact on how each type of grill works and on which one might make more sense for your family.
Charcoal grills use burning coals to produce heat. They’re usually round and feature a removable lid, a round “bowl”, and a burner located directly underneath.
Price: Charcoal grills are usually less expensive than gas grills, though high-end options can cost as much or more than some gas grills.
Flavor: Many grillers prefer the smoky flavor only a charcoal grill can provide.
Convenience: Charcoal grills can take 20-30 minutes to reach 600 degrees (or higher), the temperature needed to sear meat.
Control: It can take a lot of practice to dial in the temperature of your charcoal grill.
Gas grills use a propane tank to heat a covered grilling surface. These grills are usually rectangular and feature a flip-open lid and side “wings” that provide space for food preparation; some also have a griddle or a second mini grill.
Convenience: Gas grills start with the twist of an ignition button and can reach 600 degrees in just a few minutes.
Control: The ability to adjust heat precisely makes cooking on a gas grill much easier than on a charcoal grill, which opens up more meal options, including pizza and even desserts like pie!
Price: Entry-level grills usually cost more than charcoal grills, and premium options can run thousands of dollars.
Fuel: A bag of charcoal usually lasts only 3-5 grilling sessions, while a propane tank provides months of regular use. We typically find that most of our customers can go Memorial Day to Labor Day on a single tank, even if they’re grilling out 2-3 nights a week.
Related: How to Clean Your Grill
Choosing the right grill really comes down to a few criteria:
Here’s how to choose the best type of grill for your family based on these three criteria:
For most families, we find that gas grills are more convenient, which means they get more use. We’ll help you find the best gas grill for your home and budget, and we’re always ready to share our favorite grilling tips!
We’re proud to be a locally-owned appliance store located in the heart of Traverse City. We’ve served Northern Michigan for generations with reliable grill sales and service. See what friendly, professional customer service can do for you; shop our Downtown Traverse City showroom or start your grill search by calling our team today at (231) 947-6830!
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook
2026
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2017
Comments
There are currently no comments
New Comment